Mutual funds vs Stocks: Which is Better?

Market-linked financial products like stocks and mutual funds offer a great way to let your money work for you and grow over time. But when there's information incoming from different directions, it's only natural to get confused, more so if you're new to investing. 

So, it's no surprise most investors often end up asking this question: which is better - stocks or mutual funds? But before we answer that, let's first break down the basics.

What are stocks?

A stock – or a company's "equity" – is a type of financial instrument representing your share in the company. When you purchase a company's stock, you invest money in a company share and become a partial owner of its earnings and assets.

What are mutual funds?

A mutual fund is a financial instrument that allows multiple investors to pool money and create a corpus. It is managed by an asset management company (AMC) through a fund manager, who decides when and where to invest the amount.

They can invest the money in bonds, money market instruments, equities, or other securities depending on the investment mandate – a set of instructions on how to use the pooled amount.

Additional Read: How to Invest in Mutual Funds

Mutual fund vs shares

The pros and cons of stocks

Pros:

- Potential for high returns: Stocks have the potential to generate higher returns compared to many other investment options over the long term.

- Ownership stake: Owning stocks means owning a part of a company. It gives shareholders voting rights and potential dividends.

- Liquidity: Stocks are traded on stock exchanges, offering relatively easy buying and selling opportunities.

- Hedge against inflation: Stocks can potentially offer protection against inflation as companies may raise prices or benefit from economic growth.

Cons:

- High volatility: Stock prices can fluctuate significantly in the short term, leading to potential losses.

- Risk of loss: There's a risk of losing part or all of your investment if a company performs poorly or goes bankrupt.

- Requires research: Successful stock investments require thorough research and understanding of financial markets and individual companies.

The pros and cons of mutual funds

Pros:

- Diversification: Mutual funds pool money from multiple investors to invest in a diversified portfolio of stocks, bonds, or other securities, reducing individual risk.

- Professional management: Mutual funds are managed by experienced fund managers who make investment decisions based on research and analysis.

- Accessibility: Mutual funds are easily accessible for retail investors with lower initial investment requirements compared to direct investment in stocks or bonds.

- Cost-effective: Mutual funds spread costs across a large number of investors, reducing transaction costs.

Cons

- Fees and expenses: Mutual funds charge management fees and other expenses, which can reduce overall returns.

- Limited control: Investors have limited control over specific securities held in the fund's portfolio, as investment decisions are made by the fund manager.

- Market risk: Mutual fund investments are subject to market fluctuations and may incur losses depending on market conditions.

So, mutual funds vs stocks: which is better?

The choice will ultimately boil down to your preferred investment style and factors like:

• Diversification
• Risk appetite
• Expenses
• Tax benefits
• Returns

Additional Read: How Mutual Funds are Taxed

If you consider the risk involved, funds are more suitable investment options than stocks if you've just arrived on the investment scene. While low on returns compared to stocks, they're much safer options.

But if you're a seasoned player well into the game, the stock market offers tremendous growth pockets where you can put your money to multiply.

Also, funds don't allow you any control over the investments. If you want to sell some stocks in your portfolio, it's a call only the fund manager can take, not you. On the contrary, if you're investing in stocks independently, you'll have more control over your portfolio.

In any case, investing time to understand the stock market before investing your money is the way to go.

Over to you

While there's no clear answer to the "mutual fund or stock market, which is better?" tussle, it's always prudent to pay due diligence. With Tata Capital's Moneyfy app, you can choose from different fund schemes and set goals to enjoy a smooth investment journey. Learn more here.

FAQs for mutual funds vs shares

1. Which is safer, mutual fund or shares?

Mutual funds are generally considered safer than individual shares because they diversify their investment across a variety of stocks or bonds to spread risk.

2. What are the different types of shares?

The different types of shares include ordinary shares and preference shares.

3. What is the difference between shares and mutual funds?

Shares refer to individual ownership in a company, where you purchase stock of specific companies. Mutual funds, on the other hand, are investment vehicles that pool money from multiple investors to invest in a diversified portfolio of stocks, bonds, or other securities.

4. What exactly do you mean by "mutual funds"?

Mutual funds are investment funds that pool money from multiple investors to invest in diversified portfolios of stocks, bonds, or other securities. They are managed by professional fund managers and provide investors with access to a broader range of investment opportunities.

5. What exactly do you mean by "shares"?

Shares represent ownership in a company. When individuals buy shares of a company, they become shareholders and own a portion of that company.